| Status | |
| Owner | |
| Stakeholders |
Decision: OPTION 1 : MTR on Windows (MTRoW) Decision made by: ievgen.bezkorovainyi-ext@syensqo.com ; STINCHCOMBE, Sam ; paul.anton@syensqo.com; TRIFFAUX, Eric Date: |
Deploy a Microsoft Teams Room solution that is fast to implement, fully maintainable, and aligned with a long‑term global standard.
reuse existing meeting room equipment when possible.
Given that we have M365 E5, Intune and Logitech equipments already :
OPTION 1 : MTR on Windows (MTRoW)
Why choose the Windows path (Dell + Rally Bar)?
This architecture ensures that the meeting room becomes a first-class citizen in the Microsoft 365 tenant, benefiting from the same security and monitoring tools as the rest of the IT park.
Your current path: Dell OptiPlex 7000 Micro + Logitech Rally Bar (USB Mode)
Pros (Advantages) | Cons (Disadvantages) |
Feature Lead: Receives new Microsoft features first (e.g., advanced Front Row, multi-stream video). | Higher Complexity: More points of failure (PC + Camera + Console + separate cabling). |
Enterprise Management: Fully managed via Intune like any other Windows PC. Full support for Conditional Access and Compliance Policies. | Maintenance: As a Windows device, it requires OS patching, antivirus, and BIOS updates. |
Hardware Flexibility: Can support multiple cameras, external DSPs, and complex audio for large boardrooms. | Setup Time: Requires more manual configuration (Windows IoT image, account login). |
High Performance: The Dell i5/i7 CPU handles 4K content and heavy multitasking better than mobile chips. | Cable Management: Requires a "USB-over-CAT" or long USB cables between the table and the screen. |
Scalability: Modular design allows for independent upgrades of the PC or the Camera. | |
Advanced Features: Native support for "Intelligent Speaker" and complex multi-screen layouts. |
Alternative: Logitech Rally Bar in "Appliance Mode" (No PC required)
Pros (Advantages) | Cons (Disadvantages) |
Simplicity: All-in-one design. Fewer cables, faster physical installation (Power + HDMI + Network). | Feature Lag: Some Microsoft features arrive 3–6 months later than on Windows. |
Lower TCO: No separate PC to buy or maintain. Reduced power consumption. | Limited Expansion: Harder to add 3rd party mics or extra cameras without proprietary hubs. |
Stability: Custom-built firmware is often more stable than a general-purpose Windows OS, with fewer background processes. | Management Silo: Managed primarily via the Teams Admin Center (TAC) or Logitech Sync, less so via GPO/Intune. |
Instant-On: Faster boot times and recovery after a power outage. | Interoperability: Guest Join (Zoom/Webex) is supported but can be less fluid than the Windows Edge-based version. |
Hardware Locked: If the camera fails or becomes obsolete, the entire compute unit must usually be replaced. |
Feature | MTR on Windows (Selected) | MTR on Android (Appliance) |
Hardware | Modular: Dell PC + Logitech Rally Bar | All-in-One: Integrated Bar |
OS Management | Intune / Entra ID: Full Windows IoT | TAC / Intune: Android AOSP |
Feature Velocity | First: Receives new features first | Delayed: 3-6 month lag typically |
Interoperability | Superior: Direct Guest Join (Zoom/Webex) | Standard: Basic Guest Join |
Flexibility | High: Supports custom DSP & multi-cam | Limited: Closed hardware ecosystem |
Ease of Deployment | Low/Medium | High |
Ease of Management | High (Standardized) | Medium (Siloed) |
Scalability | High (Modular) | Medium (Fixed) |
User Experience | Premium (Full Features) | Standard |