You are viewing an old version of this page. View the current version.

Compare with Current View Page History

« Previous Version 34 Next »

This page aims to bring an architectural quality attribute evaluation over the solutions vendor alternatives.


Evaluation Matrix - Architectural Quality Attributes

1Alternative/Evaluation Vectoragilab.comalchemy.comrevvity.com
2Technical DebtsPaid


Added


3Major Work Block



4Scalability

check mark buttoncheck mark button

Architecture relies on a monolithic approach atop Oracle platform (database), what in one hand side can bring the best performance, in general; in another hand, can become complex and expensive to scale.  

check mark buttoncheck mark buttoncheck mark button

By leveraging microservice architecture in a cloud native platform, scalability can be achieved more effectively

check mark buttoncheck mark buttoncheck mark button

By leveraging microservice and event-driven architecture in a cloud native platform, scalability can be achieved more effectively

5Resource - Cost Efficiency

check mark buttoncheck mark button

Since the architecture is based on a monolithic approach atop Oracle platform (database), mostly the Cost Efficiency should take into account the licensing model of Oracle. What can become not efficient if, for instance, the most demanding compute power feature is not the most relevant overall.  

check mark buttoncheck mark buttoncheck mark button

By leveraging SaaS components in the most of infrastructure, the Cost Efficiency can achieved more effectively - fine-tuning each application context capacity given the specific demand on it.   

check mark buttoncheck mark buttoncheck mark button

By leveraging SaaS components in the most of infrastructure, the Cost Efficiency can achieved more effectively - fine-tuning each application context capacity given the specific demand on it.   

6Deployability

check mark buttoncheck mark buttoncheck mark button

By leveraging SaaS components in the most of infrastructure, the highest degree of deployability can be achieved at platform level via Infrastructure as Code (IaC), across multiple zones and in a well defined capacity.  

check mark buttoncheck mark buttoncheck mark button

By leveraging SaaS components in the most of infrastructure, the highest degree of deployability can be achieved at platform level via Infrastructure as Code (IaC), across multiple zones and in a well defined capacity.  

7Legal/Compliance

check mark buttoncheck mark button

Since the solution operates mainly in SaaS mode, some concerns from procurement and regional/legal perspectives can potentially create more complexity for deployment and cost efficiency quality attributes.

check mark buttoncheck mark button

Since the solution operates mainly in SaaS mode, some concerns from procurement and regional/legal perspectives can potentially create more complexity for deployment and cost efficiency quality attributes.

8Interoperability

check mark buttoncheck mark buttoncheck mark button

The solution is API-First oriented for transactional and batch data layers. From that perspective, interfaces are well organized into a catalog so interfaces can be leveraged easily for integration purposes.

check mark buttoncheck mark buttoncheck mark button

The solution is API-First oriented for transactional and batch data layers. From that perspective, interfaces are well organized into a catalog so interfaces can be leveraged easily for integration purposes.

9User Experience
check mark buttoncheck mark button

check mark buttoncheck mark button

By leveraging Responsive web design and being backed by a scalable/resilient microservice architecture the User Experience can be achieve at the highest level possible. 

check mark buttoncheck mark buttoncheck mark button

UI identity is close to the status-quo solution and it has a great experience for administrative operations. Also by leveraging Responsive web design and being backed by a scalable/resilient microservice architecture the User Experience can be achieve at the highest level possible. 

10Maintainability/Operability

check mark buttoncheck mark buttoncheck mark button

By leveraging SaaS components in the most of infrastructure, operate and maintaining can be facilitated with lower cost.

check mark buttoncheck mark buttoncheck mark button

By leveraging SaaS components in the most of infrastructure, operate and maintaining can be facilitated with lower cost.

11Extensibility

check mark buttoncheck mark buttoncheck mark button

Change management is facilitated for customization on existing features, also to onboard new features given the API available.

check mark buttoncheck mark buttoncheck mark button

Since the solution is API-First oriented for transactional and batch data layers, onboarding new feature by extending status-quo can be speedup.

check mark buttoncheck mark buttoncheck mark button

Since the solution is API-First oriented for transactional and batch data layers, onboarding new feature by extending status-quo can be speedup.

12Auditability


check mark buttoncheck mark buttoncheck mark button

Audit trail captured for edit and view actions on user-feature level and record level.

check mark buttoncheck mark button

Audit trail captured for edit and view actions on user-feature level can be shown in a dashboard (notebook).

There is not audit trail at user-data point level. 

High:       check mark buttoncheck mark buttoncheck mark button

Medium: check mark buttoncheck mark button

Low:        check mark button 



Utility Tree - Architecturally Significan Requirement

In the Utility Tree the use cases can be evaluated from the business relevancy versus the architectural complexity reasoning to accomplish the benefit.

Here the place to organize the use cases given its classification from the Architectural Quality Attribute Perspective.

(WIP)


References

LIMS

  • No labels